Curated recipes from 193 countries  •  New seasonal Mediterranean issue out now

Overview

Bahamian Rum Cake

Nassau Rum Cake; Bahamas Rum Cake; Caribbean Rum Cake; Butter Rum Cake

This bahamian rum cake recipe makes the light, moist butter cake Nassau shops sell as a souvenir: a golden vanilla bundt with rum baked into the crumb, pricked all over while warm and soaked with a hot butter-rum syrup until every slice glistens. There is no dried fruit and no dark colour here — this is a butter cake, not a fruit cake — and the pecans pressed into the pan give the top a gentle crunch. One serving is about 130 g, one slice.

The Bahamas have a long association with rum: pirates sailed ashore with it, and in the 1920s the islands became a hub for rum-running during the 14-year Prohibition period in the United States. The modern souvenir cake grew out of that history — the Bahamas Rum Cake Factory began in downtown Nassau in 2000, when founder George Bates opened a small shop for his rum cake recipe, and in 2014 the cake was recognised as the Official Rum Cake of The Bahamas, marinated in Ole Nassau Bahamian rum. Today the cakes are sold in tins in every Nassau shop and at the airport, in flavours from the original pecan to chocolate and banana, and many Bahamian home bakers make their own version — some from a yellow cake mix with pudding, as the shop cakes are said to be, and some, like this one, from scratch with butter, rum and a hot syrup soak.

Pairs well with: A scoop of vanilla ice cream or a cup of strong Bahamian coffee

Provenance

Bahamas flag Bahamas

Nassau Souvenir Cake

Latin America & Caribbean

Time Dedication

1h 20m

25m prep • 55m cook

Batch Yield

12 Servings

542 kcal per serving

1 serving ≈ 130 g

Technical Skill

Intermediate

Easy (Bundt & Syrup Soak)

Meal Timing & Digestive Fit

Breakfast

Not Advised

Lunch

Inappropriate

Dinner

Inappropriate

Snack & Tea

Ideal Light Bite

Occasions: Afternoon tea, celebrations, gifts and souvenirs, with coffee or ice cream Cost: Medium — about $2–3 per serving at home
A slice of golden rum-soaked butter cake with rum sauce, served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream

Nassau Souvenir Cake

Photo: stu_spivack, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Flickr

The Heritage Formulary

Measured Ingredients

Estimated cost: Medium — about $2–3 per serving at home (USD)

A light Bahamian butter bundt: rum in the batter, no dried fruit, soaked while warm with a hot butter-rum syrup until moist.

Execution Methodology & Culinary Technique

Step-by-Step Cooking Guide

Active 1h 20m
P

Prep Stage: Pan Greased & Pecan-Lined, Batter Mixed, Syrup Ready

25 Mins

Heat the oven to 175°C (350°F), grease a 12-cup bundt pan well and scatter the chopped pecans over the bottom and up the sides. Cream the softened butter and sugar until pale and fluffy, beat in the eggs one at a time with the vanilla, then fold in the sifted flour, baking powder and salt in turns with the milk and the 60 ml of rum. While the cake bakes, have the syrup ingredients measured and ready: butter, sugar and water for the pan, the 120 ml of rum kept aside to stir in off the heat.

Maestro Tip: Grease every ridge of the bundt pan — a rum cake that sticks tears its pecan top, and the top is the prettiest part.

  1. 1

    Heat the Oven and Prepare the Pan

    10 Mins • Prep Oven 175°C (350°F)

    Heat the oven to 175°C (350°F). Brush a 12-cup bundt pan generously with melted butter or baking spray, getting into every ridge, then scatter the 60 g of chopped pecans evenly over the bottom and sides of the pan — they will bake into the top of the finished cake. Set the pan aside while you mix the batter.

    A light dusting of flour over the greased pan, tapped out, helps the cake release cleanly.

    Done when: Pan fully greased, pecans sitting in an even layer, oven at 175°C (350°F).

  2. 2

    Cream the Butter, Sugar and Eggs

    10 Mins • Beating Room temperature, about 21°C (70°F)

    Beat the 225 g of softened butter and 300 g of sugar together for about 5 minutes until pale, fluffy and almost white. Beat in the 4 eggs one at a time, mixing well after each one, then stir in the 10 ml of vanilla extract. The batter should look smooth and creamy, with no streaks of butter left.

    Butter and eggs must both be at room temperature — cold eggs straight from the fridge will curdle the creamed butter.

    Done when: A pale, fluffy butter-sugar cream with the eggs fully beaten in and no curdled look.

  3. 3

    Fold in the Flour, Milk and Rum

    5 Mins • Folding Room temperature, about 21°C (70°F)

    Sift the 300 g of flour with the 10 g of baking powder and 3 g of salt. Add the flour to the creamed butter in three parts, alternating with the 120 ml of milk and the 60 ml of dark rum, folding gently with a spatula until you no longer see dry flour. Do not beat the batter once the flour is in. Scrape the batter into the prepared bundt pan and smooth the top.

    Fold, do not beat, once the flour goes in — beating develops gluten and makes a tough, rubbery cake instead of a tender one.

    Done when: A smooth, pale-gold batter, evenly mixed, filling the pan about three-quarters full.

  4. 4

    Bake Until Golden

    55 Mins • Baking Oven 175°C (350°F)

    Bake at 175°C (350°F) for 50–55 minutes, until the top is deep golden and a skewer pushed into the centre comes out clean with just a few moist crumbs. The cake should have pulled very slightly away from the sides of the pan, and the centre should reach about 95°C (200°F). Do not open the oven for the first 30 minutes, or the cake may sink.

    If the top is browning too fast after 40 minutes, lay a loose sheet of foil over it and finish the bake.

    Done when: Skewer comes out clean; top is deep golden; cake has pulled slightly away from the pan.

  5. 5

    Make the Butter-Rum Syrup

    10 Mins • Syrup Medium-high heat, about 175°C (350°F) at a boil

    While the cake bakes, put the 115 g of butter, 150 g of sugar and 60 ml of water in a medium saucepan over medium-high heat. Bring to a boil, stirring, and boil for 5 minutes until the sugar has dissolved and the syrup looks slightly thickened. Take the pan off the heat and carefully stir in the 120 ml of dark rum and the 5 ml of vanilla — it will bubble up, so stand back. The syrup is used hot, so make it while the cake is in its last 10 minutes.

    Always add the rum off the heat: rum stirred into boiling syrup loses its flavour, and the hot syrup can flare.

    Done when: A clear, golden syrup that coats a spoon, smelling strongly of butter and rum.

  6. 6

    Soak the Cake and Rest

    10 Mins active + 30 Mins resting Hot from the oven, about 175°C (350°F)

    As soon as the cake comes out of the oven, leave it in the pan and prick the top all over with a skewer. Slowly pour about half of the hot butter-rum syrup over the cake, letting it sink in for 5–10 minutes, then pour over the rest. Leave the cake in the pan for 30 minutes so it drinks up the syrup, then turn it out onto a plate, pecan side up. Let it cool for at least 30 minutes more before slicing — a warm cake cuts cleanly and tastes at its best.

    Pour the syrup slowly, in two rounds: a cake flooded all at once lets the syrup run down the sides instead of soaking into the crumb.

    Done when: Cake turned out cleanly, pecan top intact, surface glossy with syrup, holding its shape when sliced.

Finishing Touches & Plating

Slice the cooled cake with a long, sharp knife, wiping the blade between cuts so each slice stays clean. Serve at room temperature, plain or with a scoop of vanilla ice cream — the cake is at its moistest on the second day, once the syrup has settled right through the crumb.

Nutritional Physiology & Benefits

Nutrition

Energy

542

kcal / serving

Protein

6g

Complete AA

Carbs

58g

Complex

Fats

29g

Healthy

Per serving (12 servings · 1 serving ≈ 130 g)
Energy542 kcal
Protein6 g
Carbohydrates58 g
Fat29 g
Fibre1.2 g
Sugar38.5 g
Sodium392 mg
Per 100g
Energy417 kcal
Protein4.4 g
Carbohydrates44.8 g
Fat22.1 g
Fibre0.9 g
Sugar29.6 g
Sodium302 mg

Nutrition values are estimated — calculated from USDA FoodData Central values for the listed ingredients.

Vitamins & minerals: B vitamins and phosphorus (eggs, flour), vitamin E and magnesium (pecans), calcium (butter, milk).

Pecans Bring Healthy Fats and Fibre

The 60 g of pecans add monounsaturated fats, fibre, vitamin E and magnesium to a cake that is otherwise mostly butter and sugar — a small nutritional lift in every slice.

A Generous Slice of Quick Energy

At 542 kcal a slice, with 58.3 g of carbohydrate, one slice is a genuinely filling snack — useful as an occasional energy-dense treat, for example after a long swim or a day out.

Made From Scratch, Nothing Hidden

Flour, butter, eggs, sugar, milk and rum — a short, honest ingredient list with no preservatives or artificial flavouring, so you know exactly what is in the cake.

Food Pairings

What to Eat With

To optimize nutrient absorption and elevate the sensory depth, pair with these authentic accompaniments:

Sides

Vanilla Ice Cream

Cold, plain vanilla ice cream is the classic partner: it cools the warm, rum-soaked crumb and its creaminess softens the sweetness of the syrup, which is why Nassau shops serve the cake this way.

Fresh Mango or Pineapple

Slices of ripe mango or pineapple add bright acidity and juice beside the rich cake, balancing the butter and sugar so a second slice feels less heavy.

Drinks

Strong Black Coffee

A small cup of strong, unsweetened coffee cuts through the buttery sweetness and its bitterness makes the rum flavour stand out — the usual Bahamian way to take a sweet cake.

Full Menus

After a Bahamian Fish Dinner

A light slice of rum cake is the traditional sweet ending to a Bahamian meal of fried fish, peas and rice: the fish is savoury and salty, and the moist, sweet cake closes the meal without needing a heavy dessert.

Complete menu

Serve a slice of Bahamian rum cake with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and a cup of strong coffee after a Bahamian fish dinner — or on its own with afternoon tea, the way Nassau shops hand out their samples.

Digestive Guardrails

What NOT to Combine

To prevent digestive distress, sluggishness, or palate clash, avoid pairing the dish with these elements:

Serving It to Children or Anyone Avoiding Alcohol

This cake contains rum in the batter and in the syrup, and the syrup rum is added off the heat, so a small amount of alcohol remains in the finished cake. It is not alcohol-free and should not be served to children, or to anyone who avoids alcohol for health, pregnancy or personal reasons. This is general information, not medical advice — ask a clinician if you are unsure.

Eating a Large Slice With a Very Sweet Drink

One slice already carries 38.5 g of sugar, so pairing it with a sweet soda, a rum cocktail or a sugary coffee doubles the sugar load in one sitting. Water, black coffee or unsweetened tea is the kinder match. This is general information, not medical advice.

Skipping the Soak or Slicing It Hot

The syrup soak is what makes this cake a rum cake — without it, the crumb dries out within a day. And slicing while the cake is still hot from the oven makes it crumble, because the syrup has not yet set into the crumb.

General information only, not medical advice — consult a doctor for personal dietary decisions.

Who Should Eat It

Who Should Eat

  • General adultsA rich celebration cake — one slice with coffee or ice cream is the usual serving, not a second helping.
  • ChildrenNot suitable: the cake contains rum and a small amount of alcohol remains after baking and soaking.
  • ElderlyFine in a small slice for most older adults; the cake is soft and easy to chew, but it is high in sugar and fat, so keep portions small.
  • Pregnant womenAvoid: the cake contains alcohol from the rum, including rum added to the syrup off the heat, and pregnancy guidance is to avoid alcohol entirely.
  • Breastfeeding womenAvoid, or only eat a small slice well away from a feed: a small amount of alcohol remains in the cake. Ask a clinician if unsure.
  • AthletesA useful occasional energy-dense snack after hard training, but it is low in protein (5.7 g a slice), so it is not a recovery food on its own.
  • Weight gainHelpful in small, regular portions: 542 kcal a slice makes it an easy way to add energy, and the pecans add some healthy fats.
  • Weight lossBest kept as a rare treat — one slice is 542 kcal with 38.5 g of sugar, so a half slice with black coffee is a kinder portion.

Health Conditions — Adjust or Avoid

Conditions

  • DiabetesAbout 58.3 g of carbohydrate and 38.5 g of sugar per slice from sugar, flour and syrup — a large load. A half slice, or a rum-free version with less sugar, is a safer choice; check with your clinician or dietitian.
  • High blood pressureSodium is moderate at 392 mg a slice, mainly from baking powder and salt. The bigger concern is the sugar and saturated fat, so keep portions small and ask your clinician about frequency.
  • Kidney diseaseThe cake is low in potassium and phosphorus per slice, but it is high in sugar and the pecans add some phosphorus. Portion control matters; ask your clinician before making it a regular food.
  • GoutThe cake itself is low in purines, but alcohol can raise uric acid, and this cake retains a small amount of alcohol from the rum. Avoid during a flare and ask your clinician.
  • Stomach issuesA rich, buttery, sweet cake can worsen reflux and discomfort, especially eaten late or on an empty stomach. A small slice with tea, earlier in the day, is usually better tolerated; ask your clinician if symptoms persist.
  • Cardiovascular diseaseHigh in saturated fat (28.8 g of fat a slice, mostly from butter) and sugar, so this is an occasional treat rather than a regular food. Ask your clinician about how often it fits your diet.
  • Fatty liverHigh in added sugar and saturated fat, and it contains alcohol — all three are best limited with fatty liver. Keep it a rare, small treat and ask your clinician.
  • Food allergiesContains wheat (gluten), milk, egg and tree nuts (pecans). The pecans can be swapped for a seed topping, but the cake cannot be made gluten-, dairy- or egg-free without a different recipe. Check labels and ask a clinician if you have a severe allergy.
  • Special therapeutic dietsNot suitable for low-sugar, low-fat or alcohol-free therapeutic diets as written. A clinician or dietitian can advise on a modified version that fits your plan.

If you have a medical condition, consult your doctor before changing your diet.

Storage & Use

Storage & Use

How to store
Wrap the cooled cake tightly in cling film, then foil, and keep it in an airtight container.
In the fridge
Up to 1 week, wrapped — the rum and sugar keep it moist; bring slices to room temperature before serving.
In the freezer
Up to 3 months, wrapped in cling film and foil; thaw overnight in the fridge.
How to reheat
Warm a slice gently in a microwave for 10–15 seconds, or in a low oven at 150°C (300°F) for 5 minutes; do not overheat or the syrup will weep out.
Freezing recommended
Yes — this cake freezes very well, and the syrup keeps the crumb moist after thawing.
Signs it has spoiled
Sour or yeasty smell, mould spots, or a slimy surface — discard the cake if any appear.

More recipes to explore

A plate of golden-brown Bahamian conch fritters with two small bowls of dipping sauce Bahamas flag Bahamas 45m
Snack & Tea •Nassau Heritage

Bahamian Conch Fritters

This bahamian conch fritters recipe turns tender queen conch into crisp, golden balls: the conch is minced and folded into a cornmeal batter with onion, sweet pepper, celery and a little heat from jalapeno, then deep-fried until the outside shatters and the inside stays soft and savoury. They are the snack every Bahamian fish fry starts with, best eaten hot from the oil with cocktail sauce or a squeeze of lime. One serving is about 200 g (5 fritters).

Island Snack & Sharing

Crisp golden balls of minced queen conch, cornmeal and island peppers, fried hot and served with a cool dipping sauce.

Pairs Well With
Cocktail sauce, lime wedges & a cold Kalik beer
A plate of golden fried cracked conch with peas and rice, plantain and tartar sauce Bahamas flag Bahamas 45m
Dinner •Nassau Heritage

Bahamian Cracked Conch

This bahamian cracked conch recipe is the national dish of the Bahamas: queen conch is pounded thin — 'cracked' — dipped in seasoned flour, egg and cracker crumbs, then fried until the crust is golden and shattering while the conch inside stays tender. It arrives at the table as a proper main plate, usually beside peas and rice, with tartar sauce and lime. One serving is about 212 g.

National Dish & Island Classic

Pounded conch steaks in a crisp cracker-crumb crust, fried golden and served with peas and rice.

Pairs Well With
Peas and rice, tartar sauce & lime
Two bowls of Bahamian conch salad — finely diced raw conch with tomato, onion and peppers — garnished with orange and lime wedges at a Nassau fish-fry stall Bahamas flag Bahamas 45m
Lunch •Nassau Heritage

Bahamian Conch Salad

This bahamian conch salad recipe is the Bahamas' answer to ceviche: raw queen conch, tenderised and diced small, tossed with tomato, sweet onion, green pepper, celery and cucumber, then cured in fresh lime and orange juice with a little goat pepper heat. No stove, no frying — the citrus does the work, firming the conch and turning it opaque at the edges while the vegetables stay crisp. It is the dish Nassau's fish-fry vendors chop to order, piled high in a bowl and eaten cold with a spoon. One serving is about 362 g.

Fresh & Light Island Lunch

Raw queen conch cured in lime juice with tomato, onion and peppers, served cold as a bright, high-protein salad.

Pairs Well With
Johnny cake, crackers & a cold Kalik beer
High Protein
A slice of Bahamian guava duff — steamed guava-filled dough roll — covered in creamy butter-rum sauce on a patterned plate Bahamas flag Bahamas 1h 50m
Snack & Tea •Nassau Heritage

Bahamian Guava Duff

This bahamian guava duff recipe is the Bahamas' signature dessert: ripe guava simmered with sugar, cinnamon and allspice, spread over a soft sweet dough, rolled into a log and steamed for an hour until the spiral of pink fruit and pale dough is tender right through. It is sliced thick and served warm, with a spoonful of butter-rum sauce melting down over every slice. One serving is about 238 g (one thick slice with sauce).

Island Dessert & Celebration

Fresh guava rolled in a sweet dough, steamed until tender and sliced warm with a butter-rum sauce.

Pairs Well With
Butter-rum sauce, vanilla ice cream & a cup of tea

The Dinner Gazette

Never wonder what’s for dinner again

One email a week with easy dinner ideas from around the world — ingredients, steps and nutrition, tested in our kitchen first.

Delivered every Thursday morning. Unsubscribe anytime.